Hair Presents a School Dilemma PDF Print E-mail
Blog - Kids > School
Written by NathanG   
Wednesday, 13 January 2010 05:24

Taylor Pugh with long hairUpdate (Jan. 19, 2010) - Taylor finally allowed back in to class. See how this incidence of gender bias was resolved:
http://mesquiteblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2010/01/taylor-pugh-hair-in-french-bra.html

Update (Jan. 13, 2010) - School district sends letter warning of stricter in-school punishment if hair not dealt with.
http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/localnews/stories/DN-hairfolo_13met.ART.State.Edition1.4bc6f6b.html

ORIGINAL BLOG POST:
Taylor Pugh, a four-year-old student at Floyd Elementary School, has been spending every school day isolated from his friends and classmates because of the length of his hair. His sandy brown locks are longer than district policy allows and his original punishment was off-campus suspension. He was denied his education because of long hair.

Now, the district has modified the punishment to in-school suspension. He spends all day with a teacher's aid in a room by themselves. His parents have said he doesn't want to cut his hair and they don't plan to force the issue. The school district claims his long hair is not condusive to a constructive learning environment.

According to Dad, Delton Pugh, he "picks his battles" and believes the school district is absolutely wrong to enforce their 40-year-old policy. In an effort to compromise, the school district has told Taylor's parents that he can keep his long hair as long as it is put into cornrows and kept tight above his ears. His parents have no intention of braiding his hair. They will continue to fight.

This scenario presents a lot of issues. School boards have the right to determine to behavior and appearance codes for their schools as a means of creating a safe and productive learning environment. Similarly, parents have the right to choose their child's appearance as long as it does not interfere with the educational opportunities of other students. So who is right when it comes to Taylor? Perhaps most importantly, this is a classic example of gender bias. The Mesquite School District dress code only stipulates that boys must keep their hair short. Girls do not share this requirement. It is this distinction that, I believe, illustrates the unfair policy of the district. If the length of a girl's hair does not impinge on the learning environment, why does a boy's?

These are pictures from the district website. Clearly, girls can learn with long hair. Perhaps they think boys aren't capable of such feats.

What do you think? Should the district change its policy or should Mom and Dad put education before style and cut Taylor's hair? What would you do?

Original article: http://wcco.com/watercooler/taylor.pugh.hair.2.1420680.html

Comments (6)
Re:
6 Tuesday, 13 July 2010 10:14
HesterMadelyn
Set your life time easier take the personal loans and all you require.
Texas Proud !
5 Thursday, 22 April 2010 18:39
April
I do not agree with the school districts approach to this matter. I find it to be complete nonsense ! With this being said to the jerk who posted that simply because it is an issue in Texas it explains the closed mindness of the situation I say "kiss my grits"!!! Yes a place in Texas has decided to single out this young man for what they deem to be not appropriate hair does this then mean that all Texans agree? Hell no! I kind of wonder what kind of ass backwards person would have made a judgement like that! You should be ashamed you close minded hypocritical jerk !
Ridiculous
4 Thursday, 14 January 2010 06:33
Daddy Files
The school officials are a bunch of morons and they have no right to do this to the kid. Besides, I bet girls are allowed to wear their hair long right? Why should it be any different for boys?

I wondered what kind of backwards ass place in the U.S. would institute this kind of rule, and then I saw it was Texas. And then it all made sense...
Hair affects learning?
3 Wednesday, 13 January 2010 19:37
Jillian Snyder
I would fight this battle for my child at any age. It's absolute nonsense. I understand setting a dress code, but kids should be free to express themselves to some extent. We want our kids to have a personality, don't we?? This is certainly a double standard and could probably easily be brought to court. Good for his parents!
long, beautiful hair
2 Wednesday, 13 January 2010 09:19
Whit
I'm not a lawsuit kind of guy, but it seems that the parents here might have one. And since when are cornrows a good look on anyone?

If I was a parent in that district I'd be rather upset that my tax dollars were paying for an aide in this situation - or is the school made of money?
Too Picky
1 Wednesday, 13 January 2010 06:24
Torc
Talk about keeping to the letter of the law!

Personally I do not think there should be an issue with this. He is only four years old for Pete's sake!

But I can understand the schools side of things. In the world long hair on men is not seen in the white collar world very often and certainly less often at entry level. School is supposed to prepair them for the world outside school and a tidy haircut is a must.

I would fight it at this age if my son was in those shoes.

Add your comment

Your name:
Subject:
Comment:
 
 

The ProActiveDads blog is a source of knowledge and entertainment for Dads or anyone else looking to learn and have a positive parenting experience. Posts may be submitted by anyone to feedback@ProActiveDads.com or shared via our Twitter, Facebook, or MySpace sites. All contributors will receive a link to their site and the original article.


"OurBlogIsYourBlog"
ProActiveDads is about good fathering and positive media portrayal. There are many great Dad blogs in the world and we want to help wherever we can. If you would like us to post your blogs or link to them, please contact us at feedback@ProActiveDads.com and we'll let you know how to submit your entries. Its a simple, easy, and free means of promotion for your work!